Comparison
FormVault vs DragonFly Athletics
DragonFly is distributed free through state athletic associations. FormVault is the platform athletic directors choose when they want clearance software that actually works for their program.
DragonFly Athletics is used by over 7,000 high schools across 20+ state associations, primarily because those state associations have adopted it as the NFHS-partnered platform for their member schools. The free pricing model and statewide rollout have driven significant penetration. However, there is an important distinction in this market: adoption driven by state mandate is not the same as adoption driven by product quality. When you look at independent reviews — the DragonFly Coaches app holds a 1.5 out of 5 stars on the App Store — it is clear that many of the coaches and athletic directors using DragonFly did not choose it. They were handed it. FormVault exists for the ADs and coaches who want to choose.
What DragonFly Athletics does well
An honest assessment — not a takedown.
Free for schools via NFHS subsidy
DragonFly is provided at no cost to schools in states that have adopted it as their NFHS-partnered platform. For budget-constrained districts, zero cost is a real advantage — even if the product has limitations.
State association integration
In states that have adopted DragonFly, it connects directly to the state association's eligibility and officiating workflows. If your state association uses DragonFly, your school's data flows into state systems automatically — no manual export required.
Broad user base
1,000,000+ student-athletes are already in the DragonFly system. In states with full adoption, parents and athletes may already have accounts, reducing the onboarding friction for new seasons.
How they compare
Based on publicly available information as of June 2026. Competitor details sourced from their official websites and public documentation.
Where FormVault goes further
A tool you choose is a tool that works for you
DragonFly's penetration is driven largely by state association mandates — schools in adopting states use it because they have to, not because it was the best option evaluated during a procurement process. When a product is mandated rather than chosen, user experience tends to suffer because there is no competitive pressure to improve it. FormVault competes for every school it signs. That changes how we build.
Custom forms — not state-association templates
DragonFly's forms are pre-built by the state association. Individual schools cannot create their own forms or modify existing ones. FormVault's form builder lets any AD create, edit, and deploy custom forms for any sport, event, or compliance requirement without going through anyone else. A custom waiver for off-campus travel, a sport-specific health questionnaire, a coach acknowledgment form — all buildable in minutes.
E-signatures with a real audit trail
DragonFly's digital signing is a basic mobile app submission with no named e-signature standard, no stated compliance with the ESIGN Act, and no documented audit trail for individual signatures. FormVault's multi-party signature workflow is ESIGN Act-compliant, logs each signer's identity and timestamp, and sequences signatures so that no step can be completed out of order. That chain of custody is what protects a school when a signature is disputed.
Support that actually answers
Independent reviews of DragonFly describe an inability to reach live support, calls that drop, and unresolved payment issues. FormVault is a direct-sales product — your school works with the same team that built the platform. Founding school customers have weekly check-ins during onboarding. That level of support is not possible when a platform serves 7,000 schools via a state association distribution model.
The bottom line
If your state association has adopted DragonFly and its state-level eligibility integration is essential to your workflow, that is a real lock-in factor worth weighing. If you are in a state where DragonFly is optional or absent, or if you are an AD frustrated with a mandated tool you did not choose, FormVault is worth a 60-day trial. You will see the difference in the first clearance campaign.
Common questions
Can I use FormVault if my state uses DragonFly?
In most cases, yes. DragonFly's state association integration typically covers eligibility certification and official registration — workflows that are separate from your school's internal clearance process. Many schools run their own clearance and form management through a different platform while still fulfilling their state association's reporting requirements. Check with your state association to understand exactly which workflows require their platform.
Why does DragonFly have such low App Store ratings?
The DragonFly Coaches app holds a 1.5 out of 5 stars on the App Store as of our research. Reviewers cite missing features (eligibility document management listed as 'coming soon'), bugs that prevent basic navigation, and functionality that was available in older versions being removed. The pattern in reviews suggests that coaches are using the app because their state association requires it, not because it is the best available tool.
DragonFly is free. Why would I pay for FormVault?
Free is the right price for a tool that does what you need. If DragonFly's state-association templates cover your forms, its basic app submission covers your clearance workflow, and the support model works for your school, free is hard to beat. FormVault costs money because it provides a custom form builder, ESIGN Act-compliant e-signatures with a full audit trail, a 84-event FERPA compliance log, and direct school support. Whether that is worth the subscription depends on how much your program depends on those things.
Does FormVault integrate with NFHS state systems?
Not currently. FormVault focuses on the school-level clearance and form management workflow. State eligibility report generation is on the roadmap — when it ships, exporting your clearance data in state-required formats will be a one-click operation.
Can I run both DragonFly and FormVault at the same school?
Yes. Some ADs use DragonFly for state association reporting requirements while running FormVault for their internal clearance campaigns and form management. The two systems handle different workflows and do not conflict. That said, most ADs prefer a single clearance tool — the goal of FormVault is to be that tool.
Try it yourself
See the difference in your first clearance campaign
60-day free trial. Full platform access. No credit card required. Import your roster and run a real campaign before you commit to anything.
No credit card required · Cancel anytime